Uhh, thats kind of hard. Well Roy uses flame alchemy and Ed is just.. A full metal alchemist.
So confusing. But I guess I'll stick with Ed.
*Tragic*Priestess*- 03-16-2006
They sort of had a battle but it never finished.
I still think Ed would win, but the battle would be close. Ed's skills have majorly improved since his last battle with Roy, so I'm sure he could take him.
Black Knight- 03-16-2006
Yeah, I saw him and Roy fight, I think the first fight they had Ed lost right?